At 11/5/03 6:02 PM, Mark E. Mallett wrote:
>> 1. In the line "ICANN, the organization responsible for the stable
>> operation of the Domain Name System...", "Domain Name System" should not
>> be capitalized.
>
>I would capitalize it, as it's a proper name for a specific thing.
>It's "The Domain Name System" as opposed to "a domain name system."
Well, I'd certainly agree about capitalizing proper nouns; I still
capitalize Internet and Web, both of which are a losing battle, I fear.
I don't think "domain name system" (or its acronym "DNS") is a proper
noun, though, is it? You rarely see people say "the Domain Name System"
or "the DNS" in the same way they refer to "the Web" or "the Internet".
If "the DNS" is common usage in phrases like "my server is part of the
DNS" or "my server sent a query to the DNS", then you're quite right; it
is a proper noun and should be capitalized. That kind of usage seems
rare-to-nonexistent to me, though. Hmmmm.
(The phrase "DNS" is correctly always capitalized because it's an
acronym, of course, but that doesn't necessarily mean it should be
capitalized when written out in full.)
>> 2. At the end of that sentence, there are two spaces instead of one
>> between "registration. Please".
>
>Supposed to be two spaces between the end of a sentence and the
>start of the next. Looks proper to me.
Some people do use two spaces, mostly because they were taught to do so
in typewriter classes for typewriter-specific reasons. I guess you could
make an argument that e-mail also tends to be read in monospaced fonts,
and therefore should be subject to the same rules as typewriters... but
even if you buy that argument, the vast majority of people use only a
single space in e-mail, which means that an extra space would look odd
compared to the rest of the message a reseller supplies. And things that
look odd look like typos, which is bad.
(Style guides also say that two spaces is wrong, but they're assuming
you're going to be using proportional fonts, so I'll concede they might
not be particularly relevant in this case.)
Anyhoo, based on other messages, the number of spaces between sentences
appears to be something people feel strongly about, and it's the most
minor complaint I had. I hereby withdraw my objection to that if OpenSRS
will fix at least items 3 and 4 of my original list :-)
-- Robert L Mathews, Tiger Technologies http://www.tigertech.net/
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.3 : Tue Oct 19 2004 - 23:37:50 EDT